This website requires certain cookies to work and uses other cookies to help you have the best experience. By visiting this website, certain cookies have already been set, which you may delete and block. By closing this message or continuing to use our site, you agree to the use of cookies. Visit our updated privacy and cookie policy to learn more.
This Website Uses Cookies
By closing this message or continuing to use our site, you agree to our cookie policy. Learn More
This website requires certain cookies to work and uses other cookies to help you have the best experience. By visiting this website, certain cookies have already been set, which you may delete and block. By closing this message or continuing to use our site, you agree to the use of cookies. Visit our updated privacy and cookie policy to learn more.
SDMmag logo
search
cart
facebook twitter linkedin youtube
  • Sign In
  • Create Account
  • Sign Out
  • My Account
SDMmag logo
  • Home
  • Magazine
    • Current Issue
    • Digital Editions
    • Archives
    • Monitoring Today
    • Professional Security Canada
  • Products
  • Newswire
  • Exclusives
    • SDM 100 Report
    • Top Systems Integrators Report
    • Annual Industry Forecast
    • State of the Market Series
    • Dealer of the Year
    • Systems Integrator of the Year
    • TMA Monitoring Center Excellence Awards
    • Blog
    • PSA Leadership Institute
  • Topics
    • Trends & Industry Issues
    • Video Solutions
    • Access Control & Identification
    • Smart Home
    • More SDM Topics
  • Columns
    • Editor's Angle
    • 5-Minute Tech Quiz
    • Security & the Law
    • Security Networkings
    • Digital Shuffle
    • Technology @ Work
    • Insider News & Business
    • Today's Systems Integrator
    • Marketing Madmen
    • Sales Stars
    • Smart Insights
  • Events
    • Industry Calendar
    • SDM 100 Gala @ ESX
    • Webinars
  • More
    • Videos
    • Podcasts
    • ISC West 2019
    • Photo Galleries
    • Newsletters
    • Classified Ads
    • SDM Store
    • White Papers
    • Sponsor Insights
    • More Resources
  • Directories
    • Buyers Guide
    • Take a Tour
    • Guide to Distributors
    • Guide to Central Stations & Monitoring
  • Contact
  • Advertise
Home » Is Alarm Company Responsible for Plaintiff’s Flood Damage?
SDM TopicsSecurity & the LawColumnsLife Safety & Fire AlarmStandards, Regulations & Legislation
Security & the Law

Is Alarm Company Responsible for Plaintiff’s Flood Damage?

Security  Law 2019
December 3, 2019
Lessing E. Gold
KEYWORDS fire detection / fire sprinklers / insurance / law / life safety / security industry
Reprints
No Comments

A recent action was filed in the United States District Court of Nevada where the plaintiff, owner of a building, entered into a contract with the defendant alarm company’s predecessor for security services at the building, including monitoring alarms and dispatching responses to alarms. The contract was apparently subsequently assigned to the defendant alarm company.  

On a Saturday in December 2018, the defendant informed the plaintiff that the fire alarm was triggered in the building. The plaintiff told the defendant to send a dispatch response because no one was available. The defendant reported back that everything was fine at the building. The next day, the same thing occurred. On Monday, the plaintiff discovered the building was flooded and according to remediation service providers, the amount of water was consistent with three days’ worth of flooding.  

The plaintiff filed suit, asserting claims for negligence, breach of contract for failing to respond to the two alarms, and breach of the implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing. The defendant moved to dismiss, arguing that the negligence claim is barred by the economic loss doctrine; the contract between the parties limits the damages defendant can recover to 10 percent of the annual service charges or $1,000, whichever is greater; and the claim for breach of the covenant of good faith and fair dealing does not allege a basis that is independent of the breach of contract claim.

Regarding the economic loss claim, the plaintiff claimed it suffered property damage so it was not pursuing purely economic loss. The Supreme Court of Nevada concluded that a defective component of a building does not cause property damage within the meaning of the economic loss doctrine where the component damages only itself and the building of which it is an integral part. Here, even if the fire alarm was considered an integral part of the building, the alarm is not what failed. Instead, the plaintiff alleges it was the defendant’s negligent response to the alarm that caused damage by allowing the flooding to continue unabated for days. The defendant’s response to an alarm is not an integral part of the building such that it could be said the building essentially injured itself. The court therefore denied this portion of the motion.  

Regarding the contractual exculpation and limit of liability clauses in the contract, the contract was originally entered into between the plaintiff and a prior security company. The defendant asserts the contract was assigned to them. The court declined to consider this document because the plaintiff disputed that the original contract is the one that governed the relationship between it and the defendant at the time of the events at issue. The plaintiff disputed the authenticity of the contract as being the contract on which its claims are based. The court therefore denied the defendant’s motion to the extent it is based on the provisions of the original 2004 contract.

Regarding the breach of the covenant of good faith and fair dealing, it is well-established that a claim alleging breach cannot be based on the same conduct establishing a separately pled breach of contract claim. The complaint as currently plead alleged the same conduct for the breach of contract claim and the claim for breach of the implied covenant. By alleging that defendant breached the contract by failing to thoroughly respond to the first and second alarms, the complaint fails to adequately allege a breach of the implied covenant. However, the court granted the plaintiff leave to amend its claim because it was not clear that the amendment would be futile.  

The court therefore ordered that the defendant’s motion to dismiss be granted as to the claim for breach of the covenant of good faith and fair dealing. The motion to dismiss was denied in all other aspects. It will be interesting to see what happens if the case goes to trial.


 

READERS ASK

Q:  I just received a letter from the city where our alarm company does business. They are requesting me to give them a list of all of my subscribers. Do I have to comply?

A: It is my understanding that many cities throughout the country are attempting to obtain a list of subscribers. This may be mandated by city ordinances.  I would not submit a list, however, without an affirming acknowledgement from the city that this list of subscribers will be held confidential and will not be distributed to any party, even under the Freedom of Information Act. Bottom line, do not supply this information unless you absolutely have to.

Subscribe to SDM Magazine

Recent Articles by Lessing Gold

Can Insurance Company Recoup in Fire Sprinkler Case?

Does Monitoring Contract With Tenants Entitle Building Insurance Provider to Reimbursement?

Prominent Liability Clause Protects an Alarm Company That Failed to Respond

Burglar Alarm Responding Sheriff Causes Traffic Accident — Was he Liable?

Les-gold-dscf0001

Lessing E. Gold of Mitchell, Silberberg & Knupp is counsel to the California Alarm Association and a contributing legal columnist. He can be reached at sdm@bnpmedia.com.

Related Articles

Is Security Company Responsible for Loss of Property Value?

Justice Prevails in Alarm Company Contract Termination Case

Was a Property Damage Suit Filed too Late?

Who's Responsible for Third- Party Dealers’ Violations?

You must login or register in order to post a comment.

Report Abusive Comment

Subscribe For Free!
  • Print & Digital Edition Subscriptions
  • SDM eNewsletter & Other eNews Alerts
  • Online Registration
  • Subscription Customer Service

More Videos

Sponsored Content What Is Sponsored Content

Sponsored Content is a special paid section where industry companies provide high quality, objective, non-commercial content around topics of interest to the SDM audience. All Sponsored Content is supplied by the advertising company. Interested in participating in our Sponsored Content section? Contact your local rep.

Close
Featureimage_900x550__ovl0jlkbbj__
Sponsored By
Schneider Electric

New Digital Load Management System Drives Productivity and Enables New Business Models

Motor starter selection and configuration has always been a labor-intensive task. To address this challenge, machine builders and system integrators must adopt new technologies that simplify motor starter selection, installation, configuration and maintenance.

Popular Stories

Dealer of the Year(2019)

SDM 2019 Dealer of the Year: CPI Security of Charlotte, NC

ACT365-ipad

3 Reasons You Should Be Offering Cloud-Based Access Control

STANLEY

STANLEY Security Partners With Indianapolis Colts to Honor Local ‘Security Champion’

GettyImages-1087183206

Whatever Happened to the Prediction of a Mass Extinction of Security Dealers?

ADT Commercial

ADT Commercial Purchases Critical Systems of Georgia

SDM 2019 Top Systems Integrators Report

Events

January 1, 2030

Webinar Sponsorship Information

For webinar sponsorship information, visit www.bnpevents.com/webinars or email webinars@bnpmedia.com.

View All Submit An Event

Poll

Hiring Women in Security

Has your company made any efforts in the past year to specifically hire and/or promote women in managerial/executive positions? (Please select the best answer.)
View Results Poll Archive

Products

Contemporary Security Management, 4th Edition

Contemporary Security Management, 4th Edition

 Contemporary Security Management, 3rd Edition teaches security professionals how to operate an efficient security department and how to integrate smoothly with other groups inside and outside their own organizations. 

See More Products

SDM Magazine

_FC_SDM1219 cover 144x192

2019 December

Check out SDM Magazine’s December 2019 issue, featuring "CPI’s Key to Success Is Controlling ‘the Experience’ in-House", "Monitoring Services: The Cutting Edge", and much more.

Check back throughout the month for new content!

View More Create Account
  • Resources
    • List Rental
    • Online Exclusives
    • Industry Innovations
    • Partners
    • Privacy Policy
    • Survey And Sample
  • Want More
    • Subscribe
    • Connect

Copyright ©2019. All Rights Reserved BNP Media.

Design, CMS, Hosting & Web Development :: ePublishing