This website requires certain cookies to work and uses other cookies to help you have the best experience. By visiting this website, certain cookies have already been set, which you may delete and block. By closing this message or continuing to use our site, you agree to the use of cookies. Visit our updated privacy and cookie policy to learn more.
This Website Uses Cookies
By closing this message or continuing to use our site, you agree to our cookie policy. Learn More
This website requires certain cookies to work and uses other cookies to help you have the best experience. By visiting this website, certain cookies have already been set, which you may delete and block. By closing this message or continuing to use our site, you agree to the use of cookies. Visit our updated privacy and cookie policy to learn more.
Subscribe
SDM Magazine
  • Sign In
  • Create Account
  • Sign Out
  • My Account
SDM Magazine
  • Home
  • Magazine
    • Current Issue
    • Digital Editions
    • Archives
    • Monitoring Today
    • Professional Security Canada
  • Products
  • Newswire
  • Exclusives
    • SDM 100 Report
    • Top Systems Integrators Report
    • Annual Industry Forecast
    • State of the Market Series
    • Dealer of the Year
    • Systems Integrator of the Year
    • TMA Monitoring Center Excellence Awards
    • Blog
    • PSA Leadership Institute
  • Topics
    • Trends & Industry Issues
    • Video Solutions
    • Access Control & Identification
    • Smart Home
    • More SDM Topics
  • Columns
    • Editor's Angle
    • 5-Minute Tech Quiz
    • Security & the Law
    • Security Networkings
    • Digital Shuffle
    • Technology @ Work
    • Insider News & Business
    • Today's Systems Integrator
    • Marketing Madmen
    • Sales Stars
    • Smart Insights
  • Events
    • Industry Calendar
    • SDM 100 Gala @ ESX
    • Webinars
  • More
    • Videos
      • ISC West 2018
      • ASIS 2017
    • Photo Galleries
    • Newsletters
    • Classified Ads
    • White Papers
    • Sponsor Insights
    • More Resources
  • Directories
    • Buyers Guide
    • Take a Tour
    • Guide to Distributors
    • Guide to Central Stations & Monitoring
  • Contact
  • Advertise
Home » Designing an Effective Product Assessment Process
Technology Solutions & Skills

Designing an Effective Product Assessment Process

Richmond Alarm ScorecardWEB.jpg

IMAGE COURTESY OF RICHMOND ALARM

Richmond Alarm identified several key categories for both customers and their business and developed a “scorecard” to evaluate potential vendors and their products.

January 21, 2019
KEYWORDS product evaluation / security dealer / security integrators
Reprints
No Comments

As the 2019 trade show and conference season ramps up, security integrators are faced with the sometimes daunting task of researching, evaluating and ultimately choosing which new products or partners they want to align themselves with. Midlothian, Va.-based Richmond Alarm, ranked No. 71 on the SDM 100, an electronic security provider that services 25,000 customers, recently constructed a system to quantify and standardize this process. Here is their story:

At Richmond Alarm we know our main objective is to deliver the most advanced security solutions for every one of our customers. It can be all too easy to keep “assessing products” on the to-do list indefinitely. Business is booming, competition is growing, ensuring the ongoing success of sales, customer service, managing staff and the bottom line is enough to fill the day, the week, and the year without engaging in a labor-intensive project. And yet, evaluating new products needs to be done on a regularly scheduled basis to ensure the business keeps up with the latest technology.

In early 2018, we resolved to streamline our product vendors, and to do so by building a product selection framework from the ground up. I formed a product committee led by Tom Kenney, our senior project manager, and comprised a team made up of representatives from sales, technical, central station, and management. In the first couple of meetings, we spent time soliciting feedback from the different departments, and came up with two working lists: customer needs and company needs.

Customer needs included:

  • ease of use – how intuitive is the system to use;
  • remote access – whether a customer can easily access the system remotely;
  • reliability – wear and tear, warranty period;
  • flexibility – scalability of the solution; and
  • integration – whether it integrates easily with other popular solutions.

Company needs were:

  • pricing – relative to competitors;
  • supply chain – whether it is purchased directly or via a distributor;
  • sales training – how is the sales team supported;
  • demo program – is demo equipment offered virtually or onsite?
  • technical training – how is the technical team supported?
  • technical support – hours, where done, wait times relative to competition;
  • legacy support – takeover options for existing customers, backwards compatibility;
  • warranty – reliability, process and length of period; and
  • service accessibility – service team access and ways to manage truck rolls.

Our team designed a vendor scorecard incorporating all these requirements, so we could objectively quantify our discoveries about each product and supplier. We embarked on a journey to ISC West, the industry’s largest trade show, to see the most expansive display of vendors in one setting. We divvied up into teams to engage with as many vendors across as many product lines as possible. Where initial scores ranked highly, we scheduled follow-up meetings for the entire team.

Once we returned to Richmond, we totaled our scores and made a shortlist of a dozen potential vendors and reached out to each one, inviting them to an on-site interview. We designed it as an interview rather than a one-way presentation, because growing their understanding of our company and needs was and is vital to a solid, ongoing business relationship. The sales teams were all professional and prompt, and surprisingly grateful when we sent them blank copies of our scorecards, so they could be fully prepared.

Having narrowed our list of suppliers to a number that we felt were promising in terms of their ability to deliver, the products themselves were going to determine our final decision. Could each product we were interested in completely integrate security/access/CCTV/fire systems? Was the customer interface of the solution easy to use and could it be easily accessed remotely? How accessible was the system for an installer?

When all presentations were complete, we compiled our results, re-engaged the top two or three in each category and entered the next phase: discussing pricing, whether we would have exclusivity of the product in the region, which distributors best represented the solution, marketing resources and support, and a timeline for commitments.

In the end, we had several takeaways that might prove useful to others. The first takeaway is that abandoning bias from the beginning of the process was critical to success. Every product we had or aspired to have, and even every relationship we had with suppliers was on the table. Opening ourselves this way enabled members of the team to speak freely about any struggles they were having, and the results were occasionally surprising.

Diversity was another: having long-term, knowledgeable employees from each department was critical not only in designing the process, but scoring suppliers and products. Features and flaws of each product and supplier took on different weighting, depending on whether the department representative thought it would positively or adversely affect their department’s future success.  Equally, serving on the committee had a positive impact in-house: everyone involved became a stakeholder in the result, which bolstered their affinity for our company and buy-in to the implementation.

Tradeshows were another: testing multiple products side-by-side at the show would have been difficult and time-consuming to duplicate in our offices, and the one-on-one meetings we had with suppliers were invaluable. As an aside, we’d suggest suppliers might want to ensure they have a process for testing demos before each show, as several companies were having issues. We’d also suggest suppliers might want to make sure they have enough representation in their booth: those that could avail themselves to those one-on-one meetings despite the busy schedule were at an advantage. 

But the biggest takeaway was protecting and improving the process we had developed so it could be duplicated on a scheduled regular basis in the future, ensuring we always stay on top of technology and can best meet our customers’ needs, now and in the future. — By Brian Vanderheyden, CEO, Richmond Alarm.

Subscribe to SDM Magazine

Related Articles

Fire-Lite Announces Online Product Improvement Process

Fire-Lite Announces Online Product Improvement Process

Thermal IP Cameras Designed For Monitoring Critical Infrastructure, Industrial Processes

Axis Encoder Designed for Analog to IP Migration Features 60 fps Processing

Related Products

Effective Physical Security, 4th Edition

Effective Security Management 6th Edition

Physical Security and Environmental Protection

Physical Security and Safety: A Field Guide for the Practitioner

Related Events

Webinar: Troubleshooting an Axis IP Network camera installation

Axis Communications Product Overview

Axis Communications Product Overview

Axis Communications Product Overview

Related Directories

DMP (Digital Monitoring Products)

ELK Products Inc.

Vitek Industrial Video Products Inc.

Alarm Products Distributors

You must login or register in order to post a comment.

Report Abusive Comment

Subscribe For Free!
  • Print & Digital Edition Subscriptions
  • SDM eNewsletter & Other eNews Alerts
  • Online Registration
  • Subscription Customer Service

More Videos

Popular Stories

SDM0219-cover inside

State of the Market: Video Surveillance

ADT-Logo1.jpg

ADT Acquires DIY Home Security Provider LifeShield

defenders.jpg

ADT Dealer DEFENDERS Draws Scrutiny From Chicago News Station

KP_KA_ChooseAlert

Beyond the Basics of Emergency & Mass Notification

legislation.jpg

Watch for Bills Regarding School Security, Occupational Licensing in 2019

SDM-IndustryInnovation360

Events

April 30, 2019

How to Work with IT to Capture the Entire Job

As modern security systems become increasingly sophisticated and camera counts continue to climb, many organizations are looking to their IT departments to find replacements for traditional infrastructure. Outdated infrastructure puts organizations at risk of data loss and downtime and potentially exposes them to critical liabilities and financial losses. It should come as no surprise then that 40-60% of the average security spend is allocated to updating infrastructure.
January 1, 2030

Webinar Sponsorship Information

For webinar sponsorship information, visit www.bnpevents.com/webinars or email webinars@bnpmedia.com.

View All Submit An Event

Poll

Hiring Women in Security

Has your company made any efforts in the past year to specifically hire and/or promote women in managerial/executive positions? (Please select the best answer.)
View Results Poll Archive

Products

Effective Security Management   6th Edition

Effective Security Management 6th Edition

This latest edition of Effective Security Management retains the qualities that made the previous editions a standard of the profession: a readable, comprehensive guide to the planning, staffing, and operation of the security function within an organization.
See More Products
State of the Market: Access Control 2018 - SDM Magazine

Visit the latest in our “State of the Market” series: Access Control 2018

SDM Magazine

_FC_SDM0219 Cover 144x192

2019 February

In our February issue we present our 2019 “State of the Market: Video Surveillance” report. Also, find out more on "Artificial Intelligence in Video Surveillance". Read about the "3 Steps for Choosing the Right Visitor Management Solutions". And discover the latest and greatest products.

View More Subscribe
  • Resources
    • List Rental
    • Online Exclusives
    • Industry Innovations
    • Partners
    • Privacy Policy
    • Survey And Sample
  • Want More
    • Subscribe
    • Connect

Copyright ©2019. All Rights Reserved BNP Media.

Design, CMS, Hosting & Web Development :: ePublishing